Double Header Sport Fishing

An Unforgettable Fishing Trip with Doubleheader Fishing Charter!

My son and I had an absolutely incredible day fishing with Doubleheader Fishing Charter in St. Thomas. From the moment we stepped on the boat, Captain Nathan was amazing. He was knowledgeable, professional, friendly, and worked incredibly hard to make sure we had the best trip possible.

The fishing was unbelievable! Captain Nathan knew exactly where to go and what to do to keep us on the fish. It was an experience that my son and I will be talking about for a long time.

What really stood out was how much Captain Nathan genuinely cared about making the trip special for us. He made the day fun, exciting, and memorable from start to finish.

If you’re looking for a fishing charter in St. Thomas, I highly recommend Doubleheader Fishing Charter and Captain Nathan. We couldn’t have asked for a better trip or a better captain!

5 stars all the way! 🎣🌴

We had a disappointing fishing charter with this company.

My concern was not simply rough water. I understand offshore fishing can be rough. The issue was the lack of safety briefing, poor communication, and the captain’s attitude.

Before leaving, we were not shown how to use the life jackets, told where the life ring was, or given man overboard instructions. My wife was also not shown how to safely use the fishing chair and we were told "we would cross that bridge when we get there" even though we never did.

The captain was abrupt and confrontational from the beginning. When I asked if we would be trolling, he yelled that we all needed to “get on the same page,” even though we later did end up trolling.

Water came onto the boat several times, and I became seasick. The captain did not check on me or discuss moving to calmer water. My wife was later told to reel in a shark from the rod holder and had pain afterward, despite asking for the chair.

I contacted the company privately first. The owner admitted the lack of safety protocols and apologized but then seemed to shift blame toward my seasickness rather than address the lack of safety briefing and captain’s conduct.

Based on our experience, I would not book with them again. There are much better Captains out there who care about safety.

Fishing with Double Header is the best St. Thomas adventure and my family and I have done it all. I can't say enough how grateful we are to Nate for his knowledge, experience skills and attentiveness. He makes the day. He is incredible with my kids and just manages all the action with such ease. We caught a ton of fish and made the best memories. Thank you Double Header and Nate. Can't wait to book out next trip.